Stay at Great Island Inn, a refined 19th-century inn in New Castle, NH. Enjoy ocean views, free Wi-Fi, and LGBTQ+ friendly atmosphere steps from the beach.
Guests consistently highlight spacious, well-appointed rooms with modern conveniences, alongside a peaceful, scenic setting close to beaches and Portsmouth. Attentive staff and nearby café options enhance the experience, making it an excellent retreat with easy access to local attractions.
GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.
Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.
Rooms, shared spaces, dining and exterior — grouped so you can skim quickly.
Housed in a warm 19th-century building, Great Island Inn offers refined studio accommodations that blend historic charm with modern amenities, including free Wi-Fi and kitchens in some units. Many rooms provide views of the Piscataqua River and the Atlantic Ocean, enhancing the peaceful and scenic atmosphere of this New Castle property. Guests appreciate thoughtful touches like in-room laundry facilities and well-stocked bathrooms, which contribute to a comfortable stay.
The inn’s location is particularly convenient for visitors seeking proximity to natural and urban attractions. It is a short two-minute walk from the nearest beach and about three miles from Portsmouth, making it easy to explore local shops, restaurants, and the nearby waterfront. Odiorne Point State Park, a popular oceanfront destination, lies just four miles away, providing additional outdoor activities.
Guest reviews frequently highlight the cleanliness and quietness of the inn, as well as the friendly and responsive staff. Several visitors note the benefit of having a café adjacent to the property that serves breakfast and baked goods. The setting in a historic neighborhood with charming narrow streets suits those looking for a peaceful retreat with easy access to both coastal scenery and nearby city amenities.
With its blend of inn, bed & breakfast, and hotel qualities, Great Island Inn is well suited for travelers who appreciate a boutique, home-like environment with practical conveniences. It is also welcoming to LGBTQ+ guests and suitable for those wanting a calm, scenic base not far from cultural and natural points of interest. Some rooms have unique layouts that might not accommodate larger furniture easily, a detail noted in guest feedback.
The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.
Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.
We LOVED our room; spacious, updated, kitchen (though we didn’t use it) is cool to have, big enough bathroom w/ a tub (and Laundry stack), impressive. IT WAS PERFECT. Service: big shout-out to Milena who answered the phone after hours to clarify/rectify something. THANK YOU:) Location: Just exquisite, a 5 min drive (or 45 min walk) to Portsmouth. Easy.
We loved our three day stay at the Great Island Inn! Our room was large, well designed and decorated with a comfortable King sized mattress and bedding. The room included a kitchen and in-room laundry as well. Also, just downstairs was a cafe that had delicious baked goods, breakfast sandwiches and salads. The island is quiet and peaceful and Portsmouth is about a 10 minute drive away. We would definitely stay here again!
Beautiful and functional apartment style room with nice touches. Wonderful location in beautiful New Castle walking distance to the beach with view of Portsmouth Harbor Lighthouse. Perfect for watching the sunrise. Delicious food at the Islander Cafe next door. Highly recommend.
I cannot recommend Great Island Inn enough; it was fantastic! Everything about it: the communication, the check-in procedure, the cleanliness, the amenities, was perfect! Additionally, the staff was very quick to respond after hours to any inquiries. The surrounding neighborhood is very charming and peaceful and it is very easy to get to Portsmouth/Kittery. As an added bonus, there is a very good cafe right next door. Look no further than the Great Island Inn, you won't regret it!
Truly one of the best places we have ever stayed. I want to be clear about how much we loved this place. First, the scents! Never underestimate the power of good smells. The lobby had one of those capillary incense bottles, and the bathrooms were well stocked with Malin+Goetz hair products, body wash, moisturizer, soaps and we were OBSESSED! I’ve never felt more refreshed and calm after a shower. The location was perfect: nautical theme, view of the water, narrow, cozy streets. The toilet had the water-saving flush mechanism I’ve only seen in Europe, the water pressure in the shower was great. Soft, comfy bed, easy parking, a white noise machine?!? And easy temperature control. Access to the washer and dryer was amazing and the kitchen was very well stocked. I will be here again!!!
We had a wonderful stay at this charming inn! The staff were incredibly friendly and made us feel right at home from the moment we arrived. Everything was spotless — from the rooms to the common areas — which made for a very comfortable experience. The location couldn’t be better, with shops, restaurants, and attractions all within walking distance. Highly recommend for anyone visiting the area! We will be back!
We had a pet friendly room with street access. Super clean and nicely remodeled. The shower was fantastic for person with bad knees :). The only downside is king size bed is too large for available space so getting around the bed was difficult and side tables very small. The room shares a wall with a small restaurant but noise was not an issue and it was super convenient for breakfast. The location is great with lots of sights within walking distance and good access to Portsmouth and Kittery. Smash like and follow if you found this review helpful.
This was our second time staying at the great island inn! Our stay was absolutely perfect! If you’re looking for a place that feels like home but offers the charm of a boutique stay, this is it. The apartment was beautifully designed, clean, and full of thoughtful touches, from the fully equipped kitchen to the in room washer & dryer, which was a lifesaver after our daily beach walks (rain or shine!). The location couldn’t be better! It’s tucked away in a quiet, historic neighborhood, yet it’s just minutes from downtown Portsmouth and Kittery, either a quick drive or a gorgeous 20-30 minute walk past historic homes, the waterfront, and over the bridges. The best part? The beach is only two blocks away with stunning lighthouse views! The bed was incredibly comfortable, and the space had so much character and attention to detail. Plus, having Islander cafe right downstairs was such a treat, amazing coffee and delicious breakfast without having to go far. If you’re looking for a peaceful, comfortable, and well-located place to stay, I can’t recommend Great Island Inn enough! We’ll definitely be back. -@nicolecasaz
A 2-minute walk from the nearest beach, this refined inn in a circa-1920 clapboard house offers views of the Piscataqua River and the Atlantic Ocean. It's 3 miles from Portsmouth and 4 miles from the oceanfront Odiorne Point State Park.
Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.
Stay at Ralfroy Motel, a 3.7star motel in Boise offering free WiFi, free parking, and kidfriendly amenities. Near Boise Art Mus...
Stay at Hotel Bixby Scottsdale with free WiFi, outdoor pool, and petfriendly rooms. Near Desert Botanical Garden, Phoenix Zoo, a...
Stay at Clarion Inn & Suites Evansville Eastland Area offering casual suites with kitchenettes, free parking, WiFi, and a gym nea...
Stay at The Meeteetse Inn in Meeteetse, WY, featuring kidfriendly service and close to Meeteetse Museums and Yellowstone Regional...
Enjoy a 4.9star stay at The Inn at Park Spring, located near Congress Street and Portland Museum of Art. Free WiFi, parking, and...
Historic country inn with gourmet dining, walking trails, and LGBTQ+ friendly amenities near James Madison's Montpelier in Locust ...
Enjoy spacious suites, free breakfast, indoor pool, and fitness center at Embassy Suites by Hilton San Diego La Jolla, close to UC...
Relax at Vero Beach Inn & Suites, a 3.8star hotel near I95 offering free WiFi, outdoor pool, kitchens, and easy access to Holma...
Stay at Holiday Inn Express & Suites Dalton, an IHG Hotel. Enjoy free breakfast, indoor pool, business center, and easy access to ...
Enjoy free WiFi, indoor pool, hot tub & free breakfast at SureStay Plus by Best Western Montrose, conveniently near Black Canyon ...
Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.
